Versions Compared

Key

  • This line was added.
  • This line was removed.
  • Formatting was changed.

...

The following graph gives a good idea on the algorithm sophistication of the different light samplers. 

Chart
width800
domainAxisUpperBound300
titleRMSE vs. RAYS
typexyLine
yLabelRMSE
domainAxisLowerBound0
xLabelMillion Rays



Rays2.453.134.517.2712.7823.845.8890.1
3Delight0.09331420.06582660.04412480.02904390.01855750.01175660.00752546

0.00449892



Rays0.6783.2610.816.9443.4173.6694.5
Arnold0.156990.1001150.05017870.03963990.02425150.01174130.00693426



Rays1.472.945.8811.721.147.0294.14376.3751.3
RenderMan/RIS0.1511250.1214870.09536490.07281480.05206060.03738760.02653880.01381480.00854045



The following graph shows the time required to achieve a certain quality. From user's perspective, this is an important quantity.

Chart
width800
titleRMSE vs. TIME
typexyLine
yLabelRMSE
xLabelTime
Time5.72s812.822220.18684037.92758672.9107165.69302.98
3Delight0.09331420.06582660.04412480.02904390.01855750.01175660.00752546

0.00449892

Time12692181492
Arnold0.156990.1001150.05017870.03963990.02425150.01174130.00693426
Time6.747.237.999.4218.5129.4098.08383.39
RenderMan/RIS0.1511250.1214870.09536490.07281480.0373876


0.02653880.01381480.00854045
The following graph shows how much time it takes to build the acceleration data structure depending on sample count.

Chart
width800
domainAxisUpperBound300
titleTime to First Pixel vs. Samples
typexyLine
yLabelTime to First Pixel
domainAxisLowerBound0
rangeAxisUpperBound50
xLabelMillion Rays
Rays2.453.134.517.2712.7823.845.8890.1
3Delight2222222

2

Rays0.6783.2610.843.4173.6694.5
Arnold00.351.23.21141
Rays1.472.945.8811.747.0294.14376.3751.3
RenderMan33.244.7915.551.297

...

Samples248163264128256
Image

Time5.72s8s12.82 s2220.18 68 s4037.92 s75s8672.9107165.69 s302.98
TTFP3333333

Shadow Rays2.45 M

3.13 M

4.51 M7.27 M12.78 M23.8 M45.88 M90.1 M
RMSE0.09331420.06582660.04412480.02904390.01855750.01175660.007525460.00449892

...